New blog

All new content on my restarted blog is here

Sunday, September 20

Postscript two: Lessons from the great 2009 Birmingham City Council website disaster



Following the almost universally badly received launch of the new Birmingham City Council website local developer Mark Steadman posted a challenge on his blog:

Why don’t those who are busy complaining and building independent fixes to problems that only concern people who know or care what hashtags are*, get together and build an alternative Council website? Something that’s a real resource for its users, and doesn’t suffer from the dearth of features the official site does.
In particular he singled out another local developer who had joined the negativity, Stef Lewandowski who describes himself as 'Creative entrepreneur and maker of social network toolbox for dads Odadeo.com - Webby winner, Clore Fellow, ideas guy, jack of all trades but master of none!', for criticism and his challenge.

Well Lewandowski has risen to it and in a matter of days has built what's been labeled #bccdiy (screengrab above).

He describes it as:
An unofficial website, aimed at providing a useful service to people in Birmingham based on the contents of the Birmingham City Council website, combined with other tools and services.
It comes from the input of people to the bccdiy wiki I mentioned in my last postcript (the wiki was set up by @jonbounds)

Thus far, I'm not aware of any reaction to this rather incredible and groundbreaking development (which you can follow on Twitter) by anyone from the council but if they don't do anything but welcome it - and it has already been suggested that they may not - then it really is time for local people to start haranguing councillors.

They could start with the Deputy Leader, Tory Paul Tilsley, who virtually came out swinging at a local event full of Birmingham's 'digerati' (or 'twitterati').



Open mouth, insert foot

#recasting was chaired by Charlie Beckett, who introduced Tilsley by praising the council's "magnificent online presence". This drew a response from Tilsley asking Beckett, "could you repeat that for the benefit of Marc Reeves" (the editor of the Birmingham Post, who have printed several articles critical of the website). Tilsley then laughed - but no-one joined in.

(Alison Smith commented on her blog post about the event "we were all too polite to heckle and I wish I had.")

Tilsey said that the council - and bear in mind the venue for his comments - was engaged in 'innovative activity' and said that the website was part of their business transformation (actually, all council's are doing this as Whitehall has instructed them to) "embracing the whole of the digital agenda over a ten year program. If you take a snaphot you have will negative comments but you need to see the whole picture."

“We’ve come in for a degree of criticism because we did spend a bit of money on it,” he said, my emphasis. “It was completely revamped and you can’t create 87,000 pages without cost.

“That was the size of the agenda that we were tackling to get a product that was responsive.

87,000?

The number that's been quoted by Glyn Evans, Birmingham City Council's Corporate Director of Business Change, thus far has been 17,000, which a lot of people have questioned (it's suggested this includes every council minute or other documents).

But it gets worse. Lewandowski says:
@stef of the 87,000 pages that were quoted I've got a functional site out of the 685 uniques I can actually find to index. #bccwebsite
Tilsley also seems to be either unaware, or actively misled, as council staff transferred the content rather than the contractor - thus adding to the £2.8m they've been forced (via FOI) to state as the website's cost.

The Deputy Leader has invited anyone with questions about the website to email him at paul.tilsley@birmingham.gov.uk. Perhaps a first question could be where he got the 87,000 figure from?

Another local councilor Robert Wright, a LibDem so part of the coalition which runs the council, has addressed - in a manner of speaking - the controversy on his blog. So there's another avenue for giving feedback to local politicians.



What may help speed things up is the arrival (albeit very late) of the Taxpayer's Alliance, who are infamous at getting themselves quoted in the media and provoking politicians into reactions.
Hang on, a £2.8m website that has taken literally years to construct isn’t world class? How much does a world class one cost then? Billions?! And if we’re to believe all the boastful publicity we’ve paid to have papered around this city, and the protestations of Cllr Mike Whitby, isn’t Birmingham a world class city? "A Global City with a Local Heart"?

Well if it is, according to this feedback, it’s a global city with a pretty crummy website…
In other feedback ...

Paul Robert Lloyd, Visual Designer at Clearleft, has pointed out that the council next door, Walsall, is doing a far, far better job (others have cited nearby Lichfield).

Ross Riley, technical director of Birmingham digital agency One Black Bear, comments on "another catastrophic disaster in a long line of public sector web projects".
The running theme throughout the site is the complete lack of even a hint of quality. There's the amateur feel of the graphics in the header, the massively bloated size of the pages, the search facility being left open to Cross Site Scripting (XSS) attacks, the painfully slow load times and the lack of any design input or consistency throughout the entire site.

There's only two possible reasons as to why this project has ended up as such an expensive disaster. Either the team running it had no expertise in online projects and failed to see that they were being overcharged for sub-standard work or someone on the project team is plotting an escape to Panama with a couple of million in notes.
On Reddit programmers find a whole stack of issues with the website.

Someone has noticed that Birmingham's Respect councillor is the only one who does not have a webpage.


Past posts:

21 comments:

  1. The first council to genuinely innovate with their website will be the one that starts with a popular, open-source CMS, builds the whole site in a transparent process with local developers and interested parties and hosts all the resulting code and data in a public version control repository. Then, creating alternative visions for the council website or submitting patches for potential inclusion on the official site will just be a "git clone" or similar away. This would help to make the council website genuinely responsive to local needs rather than something cooked up behind closed doors by the council and their contractors. No surprises. There could be a development version of the site running from day one at dev.thecouncil.gov.uk.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Absolutely spot-on Adrian.

    The BBC is experimenting with this somewhere on their site, I forget where.

    One of the things which #bccdiy underlines is that citizens can and will help. For government to turn this down should be a political issue.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Did you mean Lichfield DC rather than CC? Lichfield DC link is at: http://www.lichfielddc.gov.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  4. Steph - yes I did! Correction made to link

    ReplyDelete
  5. Paul, Are you thinking about BBC Backstage?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yes and that web history thing coming up next year

    ReplyDelete
  7. The hermes was designed with the actress Jane Birkin, According to author Stephanie Pendersen, in her book, handbag hermes What Every Woman Should Know, the handbags hermes idea first came from a plane trip Birkin took.
    lida daidaihua is the revolutionary new lida manufactured in England. Although very new to the slimming market daidaihua is already getting rave reviews and slimming capsules getting a reputation from celebrities as being a 'miracle lida slimming .' With so many diet supplements coming out of the woodwork, is this slimming capsule as effective as it is claimed to be?
    The “classic” Chanel Wallet has remained an icon throughout fashion history. The Chanel handbags design marries a chain strap, woven with leather and the renowned double C logo. The Reissue of the replica Chanel handbags offers a throwback to the era with its “mademoiselle locks” and double-chain strap.
    Do you have the feel difficult to find your favorite uk Tiffany like earrings? Now, Tiffany bracelets is your best destination. silver necklaces are well known for their highest quality and characteristic designs. We offer Tiffany accessories , drop earrings, heart earrings and so on.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anonymous6.8.10

    The fashion ed hardy shoes for girls skinny leg denim jeans is massive! There are sever ed hardy shoes al reasons for this following. Firstly, these ed hardy shoes figure squeezing jeans are well-liked by teen superstars and girls often like to emulate their most loved star. They are also very easy to wear – jeans complement everything in your wardrobe and can be dressed up or dressed down
    based on the situation. Additionally, young women and teen girls prefer ed hardy clothing to have on something their own mothers can’t, and skinny ed hardy outlet leg jeans fit this description.

    ReplyDelete
  9. seks market da ucuzluk. cinselfantaziurunleri.com Fantazi alemi aseks.com kaliteli sex shop sitesi. şişme bebek shop ürünleri. sexshop da olay. sex shop sitesi. erotik shop ürünleri hakkında. erotik market sağlık sitesi. seks shop fantazi ürünleri.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Since you are pandora jewellery going to propose cheap pandora to your special someone only once, you should cheap pandora uk make things extra special pandora discount uk by looking into antique pandora uk art deco rings. The cheap pandora necklaces luxurious and classy look of these rings make them a perfect wedding ring pandora necklaces and charms option for those who want to make their proposal more memorable and exciting.Antique art pandora beads deco rings are known for pandora beads uk their decorative structure and their geometric designs. Their intricate cheap pandora beads patterns and bold colors make them every girls dream come true.

    ReplyDelete
  11. http://tiffanyuk.livejournal.com/
    http://luxuryjewellery.microbloghost.com/
    http://www.pianetablog.com/?w=luxuryjewellery
    http://luxuryjewellery.publiku.com/
    http://tiffanyuk.sosblog.com/index.htm
    http://tiffanyuk.webs.com/apps/blog/
    http://uktiffany.weebly.com/new-blog.html
    http://blogs.bigadda.com/tif5057488/
    http://blogs.bigadda.com/jew5057294/
    http://tiffanyuk.blog.com/

    哈~_~

    ReplyDelete
  12. http://www.edisonnation.com/users/ufobag/blog_entries?page=2
    http://www.edisonnation.com/users/viagrapill/blog_entries?page=5
    http://www.edisonnation.com/users/watchedcc/blog_entries?page=2
    http://www.fabay.com/jewellerybests
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/123pandora
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/affitch80
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/againjewellery
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/classicreplica
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/enjoywatch
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/hermeslbag

    ReplyDelete
  13. I am happy to find this very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content
    TüpBebek

    ReplyDelete
  14. Greetings I recently finished reading through your blog and I'm very impressed. I do have a couple questions for you personally however. Do you think you're thinking about doing a follow-up posting about this? Will you be going to keep bringing up-to-date as well? Steve Smith

    ReplyDelete
  15. Site's character and a great color match .. Göğüs küçültme AmeliyatıI will recommend your site to the other platforms.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I enjoyed this site. Çene Cerrahisi I will recommend your site to other places. Saç Ekim Everyone does not show care. Estetik But you were preparing a site so rich in content. Estetik Burun Ameliyatı Everyone who helped, thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Comments made ??about the issues impressed me. I like your site.

    fuesacekimiistanbul

    ReplyDelete
  18. A very nice page. I think the effort has passed, we have to thank you:))
    diş çürük

    ReplyDelete
  19. Gerçek ve orjinal ürünlerin sex shop mağazası hangisi biliyormusunuz,bilmiyorsanız ben size söyliyeyim erotik shop mağazaları arasında en iyisi ve en güvenilir seks shopu türkiyede 1 numara olandır.ve bunların yanı sıra araştırmalarım içinde pornoda vardır.o kadar muhteşemki o kadar güzel sikiş filmleri varki insan izlerken resmen eriyip gidiyor fakat aralarında en çok sevdigim türk pornoları var izlerken resmen bitiyorum,gecenlerde bi arkadaşın bilgisayarında rokettubenin gerçek videoları izledim ondan sonra bi aktım ne görim sitede redtube videolarıda mevcut ve hemen arkadaşa söyledim pornolar arasında bu site en iyisidir.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Something that’s a real resource for its users, and doesn’t suffer from the dearth of features the official site does.

    Brampton Movers

    ReplyDelete
  21. a very nice site. Very useful. I will recommend your site to any environment.Estetik

    ReplyDelete