New blog

All new content on my restarted blog is here

Saturday, September 19

US health 'debate': the dangers of rhetoric and the need for responsibility



This week I posted about how the Daily Mail appears to be supporting - and making money off - the right-wing America 'Tea Party' movement.

As I added to my post, since then President Jimmy Carter has sparked debate with his comments that much of this movement is driven by racism. But there is another aspect to what's happening and that's the increasingly open threats of violence.

The USA has a long history of political violence, assassinations and home-grown terrorism. The environment is which the 'Tea Parties' and the heathcare 'debate' are happening is one where President Barack Obama is the target of more than 30 potential death threats a day and is being protected by an increasingly over-stretched and under-resourced Secret Service, according to a new book.

On 17 September, Rachel Maddow discussed on her show the rather rare emotional statement warning of violence and call for a responsible debate by Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi. Pelosi referenced the late seventies assassination of San Francisco Mayor George Moscone and Supervisor Harvey Milk. Her guest to discuss this was Cleve Jones, a colleague of Milk and the man who found his body.

In the course of the segment, Maddow discussed not only Speaker Pelosi’s view of the violence as being not unlike that of the time surrounding the assassination of Moscone and Milk, but also the incredibly irresponsible response out of Republican Minority Leader John Boehner.

There has been some legitimate debate over Carter's comments - see this for example by David Brooks in the New York Times, and the Mail carried a sensible piece by Gavin Esler - but the rhetorical tone, the toleration of protesters with guns and the inclusion (rather than exclusion) of people who are not only openly racist but also people saying that violence is legitimate?

As Maddow points out, where are the voices of the right trying to deescalate? And where is the Daily Mail?

Politicians have a choice. They can use their influence and the megaphone of their stature to further escalate the rhetoric, to try to stoke it further, to just see what might happen. Or they can use that influence, that megaphone, to try to deescalate. To get the threats of force out of our political debates. To use leadership, to ask everyone to take a deep breath before someone gets hurt. Whose doing that right now on the American right?

7 comments:

  1. When she found herself sitting next to hermes bag president Jean-Louis Dumas; and complained to Dumas that the replica hermes opening was difficult to get into, Then Hermes Birkin was asked from Dumas to draw her dream bag!
    lida daidaihua is the revolutionary new lida manufactured in England. Although very new to the slimming market daidaihua is already getting rave reviews and slimming capsules getting a reputation from celebrities as being a 'miracle lida slimming .' With so many diet supplements coming out of the woodwork, is this slimming capsule as effective as it is claimed to be?
    Great for the woman on the go, this Chanel handbags is available in a variety of stylish hues. Classic replica Chanel handbags , a double C icon, and leather strap handles distinguish this trend-setting Chanel handbag .
    A Tiffany uk is a personal expression that is all your own. Delightful Tiffany bracelets and necklaces of silver, gold or platinum will bring you the boundless joy and pleasure. Our silver bracelets are all of classical and daring design. They are all beautifully crafted, and worthy of treasuring and wearing often. Our Tiffany accessories are the poetry in motion.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous6.8.10

    The fashion ed hardy shoes for girls skinny leg denim jeans is massive! There are sever ed hardy shoes al reasons for this following. Firstly, these ed hardy shoes figure squeezing jeans are well-liked by teen superstars and girls often like to emulate their most loved star. They are also very easy to wear – jeans complement everything in your wardrobe and can be dressed up or dressed down
    based on the situation. Additionally, young women and teen girls prefer ed hardy clothing to have on something their own mothers can’t, and skinny ed hardy outlet leg jeans fit this description.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Since you are pandora jewellery going to propose cheap pandora to your special someone only once, you should cheap pandora uk make things extra special pandora discount uk by looking into antique pandora uk art deco rings. The cheap pandora necklaces luxurious and classy look of these rings make them a perfect wedding ring pandora necklaces and charms option for those who want to make their proposal more memorable and exciting.Antique art pandora beads deco rings are known for pandora beads uk their decorative structure and their geometric designs. Their intricate cheap pandora beads patterns and bold colors make them every girls dream come true.

    ReplyDelete
  4. http://tiffanyco.blog.com/
    http://tffany.blog.com/
    http://rongmairong.blog.com/
    http://tiffanyco1.blog.com/
    http://tiffanyco2.blog.com/
    http://tiffany12332199.blog.com/
    http://tiffanyuk12332100.blog.com/
    http://tiffanyco0.blog.com/
    http://www.blurty.com/users/queen45669
    http://www.blurty.com/users/rongmairong

    哈~_~

    ReplyDelete
  5. http://www.flixya.com/blog/hoganshoes1010
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/jewellerybests
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/Jewelleryrings
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/lastlvbag
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/linkslondon234
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/mbt123
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/onlyforbag
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/onlytoywatch
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/ppsjewellery
    http://www.flixya.com/blog/replicahandbags69

    ReplyDelete
  6. The advertisement the man above has is the best representation about what the people is requesting to actually heard that those strikes were also sponsored by viagra online.

    ReplyDelete